Where to buy · Etsy sellers · updated September 2026
Etsy Engagement Ring Prices: What 18 Buyers Paid
Buyers who named Etsy paid a median of $600 across 18 rings, half of them between $300 and $900. 25% of the rings whose stone was named carried moissanite. Of 41 buyers who described their own experience with Etsy, 35 recommend it, 3 are mixed and 3 warn against it.
Etsy against other Etsy sellers
| Rings from | Rings | Median | Middle half | Lab-grown share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Etsy | 18 | $600 | $300 to $900 | 25% |
| Other Etsy sellers | 216 | $500 | $300 to $800 | 15% |
The $600 median at Etsy is above the $500 median at other Etsy sellers (216 rings). Lab-grown stones made up 25% of Etsy rings against 15% at the others, which accounts for part of any gap.
What buyers said about Etsy
Of 41 buyers who described their own experience with Etsy, 35 recommend it, 3 are mixed and 3 warn against it. One line per buyer who bought or priced there themselves.
| Verdict | Price named | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Recommends | – | Go-to source for wedding-related purchases including jewelry, used repeatedly |
| Recommends | $80 to $100 | Simple 14k white gold band that fit her ring; husband's band also bought there |
| Recommends | $20 to $130 | Her $130 white gold band with channel diamonds and his $20 stainless band, both from Etsy shops |
| Recommends | $250 | Engagement ring bought there, plus one of the two cheap wedding bands; liked supporting independent sellers |
| Recommends | £400 | Bought their engagement ring here |
| Recommends | – | Bought their vintage-style ring here, says secondhand/vintage is better value |
| Recommends | £300 | Husband had a local Etsy artist hand-make a unique ring |
| Recommends | – | Husband bought an antique-style diamond ring here at a reasonable price |
| Recommends | – | Bought wedding rings and an eternity ring here, though not the engagement ring itself |
| Recommends | $200 | Sent his own stone to be set in a simple bezel ring in Argentium silver; price included the CAD design and the project took about 3 weeks. |
| Recommends | – | Had custom earrings made by this Etsy maker; he was flexible on style and referred her to another jeweler when a request fell outside his skillset |
| Recommends | – | Wedding band bought on Etsy turned out beautiful, unlike the disappointing local ring setting |
| Recommends | $60 | Bought a $60 tungsten ring that has held up over the years after local stores didn't have the right price or selection |
| Recommends | $100 | Paid a bit over $100 total for both bands working with a nicer seller on a simple design |
| Recommends | $252 | Switched here after a Patrick Adair chargeback; two custom stardust rings for $252 total, transparent communication, photos sent before shipping, delivered in about two weeks |
| Recommends | – | Had husband's wedding ring custom made on Etsy; no extra fees ordering to the Philippines, paid via PayPal, about a 3-week wait |
| Recommends | – | Buys and sells jewelry on Etsy personally and says most legitimate sellers there have good reviews |
| Recommends | $750 | Bought platinum and 18k gold wedding bands there for $750 total, versus about $4,000 quoted at Cartier-style luxury brands. |
| Recommends | $60 to $300 | Bought an onyx-and-emerald engagement ring (~$300), a matching band (~$150) and a men's ring (~$60), all from Etsy sellers |
| Recommends | – | Chose Etsy specifically to find a vintage-style ring |
| Recommends | – | Had this Etsy jeweler build the semi-mount setting for her pear stone; called them reputable. |
| Recommends | $570 | Custom 14k white gold natural diamond hoops, G color VS2 clarity, more sparkle than the Costco pair, about $570 total |
| Recommends | $2,000 | Bought two 2.5ct VVS2 E trap-cut side stones there for about $2,000 total |
| Recommends | – | Has bought several solid gold pieces from Etsy sellers that turned out to be genuinely solid gold |
| Recommends | $600 to $650 | Bought an 18k gold 3.5ct asscher-stone ring on sale from near $2,000 down to $600, plus $50 for band customization; recommends watching for Etsy sales |
| Recommends | $40 | $40 moissanite ring, no issues, no shipping or tariff charges, about a month to arrive |
| Recommends | $3,200 | Buyer has made several natural and lab-grown engagement/wedding rings through this India-based Etsy jeweler at low prices |
| Recommends | – | Bought from this Etsy seller; says they've been in business a while with excellent reviews, no price given |
| Recommends | – | Bought a stock ring from this India-based Etsy seller, in moissanite; says he also does custom work and may do lab diamonds |
| Recommends | – | Custom moissanite ring plus matching wedding bands arrived on time, as described, at about 1/20th the cost of the desired Brilliant Earth design |
| Recommends | $800 | Bought a half carat salt and pepper diamond in a 14k rose gold band for $800 |
| Recommends | C$505 | Found via his sister browsing Etsy; called it better than 99.9% of other rings he considered, cost $505 after tax |
| Recommends | – | Bought a sterling silver knife-edge triangle-profile ring there as a birthday gift to herself and liked it |
| Recommends | – | Bought the thinnest (about 1.1mm) version of a trinity-style ring from this Etsy seller and is happy with it. |
| Recommends | – | Found a secondhand vintage Stuller-brand setting on Etsy, originally sized for a 7mm stone, that ended up working well for her stone. |
| Mixed | $300 | Botched the crushed-ice stone cut and then the prong spacing twice on a custom moissanite ring, but agreed to start over from scratch and add an extra change once the buyer raised concerns |
| Mixed | $225 | Blue topaz engagement ring bought there; liked it but wished she'd seen it in person first before buying during the pandemic |
| Mixed | – | Buys loose gemstone lots from Indian Etsy sellers; requests DDP shipping to avoid tariff surcharges; uses a Presidium gem tester, and one recent seller's stones failed to test as advertised. |
| Warns | – | An attempted ring purchase fell through with a lot of drama getting the money back |
| Warns | $100 to $800 | A ring that cost about $100 a few years ago now runs $800 or more across similar Etsy listings |
| Warns | – | A seller received a similar phishing message on Etsy claiming an item had sold and asking her to scan a QR code, the first time she had seen that particular scam approach. |
Questions about buying from Etsy
How much does a Etsy engagement ring cost?
Buyers paid a median $600 for rings from Etsy across 18 purchases, half between $300 and $900.
Is Etsy good for engagement rings?
Of 41 buyers who described their own experience with Etsy, 35 recommend it, 3 are mixed and 3 warn against it.
Is Etsy cheaper than other Etsy sellers?
The $600 median at Etsy is above the $500 median at other Etsy sellers (216 rings). Lab-grown stones made up 25% of Etsy rings against 15% at the others, which accounts for part of any gap.
Is it safe to buy an engagement ring from Etsy?
Opinions split here: some buyers said to avoid Etsy jewelry entirely because of rampant stolen photos and fraud, especially from India-based shops, while working Etsy jewelers argued honest small shops exist and buyers should vet sellers by asking about their history and materials first. Opinions were mixed: one buyer liked Etsy's small-business pricing and service, but another warned not all sellers are legit after a bad experience with a different order, and said they wouldn't risk an engagement ring on an unvetted Etsy shop.
Is it safe to buy an engagement ring on Etsy?
It is generally considered safe when working directly with a well-rated seller who provides progress photos and clear listing details, though some worry about horror stories from less careful sellers. Reactions were mixed: some buyers had good experiences and said messaging the shop owner for a discount often works, but the an online group community warned that many Etsy 'jewelers' are actually scammers or drop-shippers even with good reviews.
Are Etsy sellers a good source for lab-grown diamond eternity bands?
A buyer bought two lab-grown diamond eternity bands from the Etsy seller Ouros, calling the shop hit-or-miss in general but reporting the best pricing for what she wanted, fast shipping, and a good-looking result. Buyers recommended Etsy sellers like Ouros Jewels, Kosher Diamonds and Facets and Karats for lab-grown eternity bands, and named Charles & Colvard, James Allen and Ritani as pricier options outside Etsy worth considering.
How much does a 2 carat D-color lab diamond ring cost on Etsy?
One buyer paid $1400 for a 2 carat, D-color, VS1-clarity lab diamond in white gold with IGI paperwork, catching a seller sale rather than paying full price. A buyer paid $300 for a 2ct D VS1 hearts-and-arrows round lab diamond from Starsgem, plus about $50 for shipping and tariffs.
Is it risky to buy an engagement ring from an Etsy shop?
A buyer warned that some Etsy ring photos are reused by multiple dropshipping shops with the same background, so buyers should reverse-image-search photos and cross-check prices and reviews before buying. One buyer's Etsy-bought stones fell out twice and the seller refused a refund past the 90-day window, pushing her to look for a sturdier stone and a more established seller for the replacement.
Is it safe to buy a moissanite engagement ring on etsy
Experiences are mixed: many buyers report great quality, price and communication after checking reviews with real photos, but others were scammed -- one buyer was sent cubic zirconia instead of the promised stone and could only get a refund by paying about 75% of the item's cost to ship it back to India. One experienced buyer warns most Etsy sellers should be avoided unless they're on the group's vetted vendor list, since gold and moissanite scams are common there.
About how much does a custom sterling-silver ring from an Etsy maker cost?
One buyer said a sterling-silver custom build from an Etsy seller would run roughly $250 in the US, cheap enough to use as a trial version before committing to a finer metal.
Am I overpaying for a 5-carat marquise diamond ring bought on Etsy for $5,400?
Opinions split: some said the price is fair for a rare Dutch marquise cut given current gold prices, while others found custom or local-jeweler quotes for similar or larger stones ($2,800-$3,300) much cheaper.
Are Costco or Etsy good places to buy an affordable wedding band?
One buyer said their husband's Costco wedding band was identical to a version at a local jeweler priced double and had held up for five years, while several others reported buying real gold pieces from Etsy resellers for under $350.
Are Etsy 'lab diamond' listings always real lab-grown diamonds?
No, several buyers say some shops use 'lab diamond' as a mislabel for cubic zirconia, and buyers have only discovered the switch later when a jeweler tested the stone, so an independent diamond tester or jeweler check is recommended before trusting the label.
Are Etsy engagement rings cheaper than retail jewelry stores?
A moissanite buyer said Etsy sellers don't carry the markup that traditional retail jewelry stores add, and her custom 5ct crushed-ice radiant moissanite from an Etsy maker cost $1,300 CAD.
Are Etsy engagement rings good quality and cheaper than jewelry stores?
Dozens of buyers reported custom or ready-made Etsy rings between $80 and $900, often noting similar pieces cost $1,500 or more at chain or big-box stores.
Every Etsy ring in the data
| Ring | Stone | Carat | Shape | Metal | Year | What the buyer reported |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $189 | Sapphire | 0.8 ct | – | white gold | – | Basket-set sapphire with small diamond accents, bought young on a tight budget as the closest thing to her dream ring they could afford |
| $225 | Other gemstone | – | other | – | 2021 | Blue topaz engagement ring from Etsy, priced about the same as a separate vintage ring she also bought there; wished she'd seen it in person first |
| $250 | – | – | – | – | 2021 | Engagement ring bought separately from Etsy |
| $256 | Moissanite | – | – | gold | – | Size 6, all 10k gold moissanite ring; a local jeweler verified it as well made |
| $300 | – | – | – | – | 2023 | Low-income couple hit hard by the economy; open to upgrading later or keeping this ring forever |
| $300 | – | – | – | – | – | Vintage ring bought on Etsy, described as her dream ring; resizing afterward cost $180 separately |
| $400 | Other gemstone | 2 ct | – | gold | – | 2ct cubic zirconia set in real gold, handcrafted by an Etsy maker |
| $500 | – | – | – | – | – | The actual ring he proposed with, '$500 and some change' from Scott Bonomo Diamonds on Etsy; worn every day |
| $550 | Moissanite | – | – | gold | – | 18k gold ring with a 2ct-equivalent moissanite center stone; writer loves it, paid around $500-$600 |
| $650 | Diamond, lab or natural not said | 3.5 ct | asscher | gold | – | 10th-anniversary upgrade ring, 18k gold with 3.5ct asscher stone; sale price was near $2,000, she paid $600 plus $50 for band customization |
| $800 | Lab-created coloured stone | – | – | rose gold | – | Lab-created color-change alexandrite center with lab-grown moissanite accents, rose gold band, bought as a complete ring on Etsy |
| $800 | – | – | – | – | 2024 | Bought secondhand through an Etsy resale listing, saving about $1,000 off the original price |
| $800 | Natural diamond | 0.5 ct | – | rose gold | – | Half carat salt and pepper diamond set in a 14k rose gold band |
| $900 | Lab-created coloured stone | – | – | – | 2025 | Etsy-made ring with a lab-created sapphire center and pearl accents that later came loose |
| $1,300 | Moissanite | – | pear | rose gold | 2025 | Pear moissanite engagement ring with rose gold band, side stones and matching wedding band from the same Etsy seller; fiance paid while it was on sale |
| $1,600 | Lab-grown diamond | 3 ct | marquise | gold | 2026 | Dutch marquise cut lab diamond, 14k gold, bought with a coupon from an India-based Etsy seller |
| $3,000 | Lab-grown diamond | – | – | gold | 2026 | Engaged; an Etsy maker combined design elements she liked after a local jeweler was too pricey; lab stone, solid gold, around 3k |
| $3,500 | Lab-grown diamond | 4 ct | emerald | yellow gold | 2025 | Chose the yellow gold emerald-cut option and had the Etsy jeweler upsize the center stone to 4 carats to match the competing ring; total came to about $3,500 including tax |
Sources and method
Price reports on this page come from 42 public discussions where buyers answered in their own words. Each comment that stated what someone paid became one row; notes are paraphrased, never quoted.
The largest discussions used here (42)
- 2024-01: How to respond to people?? (1381 comments)
- 2026-01: Update on 30k ring. See last post for more details (1100 comments)
- 2024-09: Considering resetting my mother's earring as an engagement ring. Thoughts? (674 comments)
- 2014-01: #JOTW Post your Cartier jewels/rings/watches! (599 comments)
- 2026-01: I don’t mean this rudely at all but is everyone posting here marrying rich guys or are my standards just not attuned to what the norm is these days? (533 comments)
- 2025-10: Welp. I love my engagement ring, but y'all were right about the pearls.... Learn from me: careful with pearls in your engagement ring!!!! (445 comments)
- 2025-01: Help me pick my Emerald cut! (443 comments)
- 2023-09: What do you consider expensive for a wedding ring? (355 comments)
- 2024-07: Absolutely mortified about getting a ring for my gf (308 comments)
- 2025-02: Thoughts on this costco ring? (226 comments)
- 2024-07: When comparing apples to apples, are Costco engagement rings cheaper than other jewelers? (216 comments)
- 2025-01: Where are y’all’s getting your engagement rings?! (208 comments)
- 2026-03: Cheap engagement ring ideas that don’t look cheap (173 comments)
- 2025-04: How do you react to comments about size? (And a thank you for your shopping advice) (172 comments)
- 2025-12: Any recommendation on cheap place to buy lab grown diamonds? (150 comments)
- 2025-08: I got engaged 7/31!! He picked the perfect ring (142 comments)
- 2026-02: Don’t Shop at Brilliant Earth: A Manifesto (141 comments)
- 2024-06: Is there a clear lacquer to fill in the nooks of this ring so it doesn't catch my hair or get dirt/lotion in it? (141 comments)
- 2023-02: I'm having a jeweler make my engagement ring. He doesn't work with customers' gems, so he's showing me the green sapphires he sourced. Do they look yellow? (136 comments)
- 2026-05: Boys, help your man out. Where to shop for affordable engagement rings? (125 comments)
- 2025-01: Tell me about your carat sizes & experiences (120 comments)
- 2024-01: Patrick Adair Jewelry review: 2+ months, weird excuses, no ring. Any ideas? (98 comments)
- 2022-03: Where can I buy an engagement ring that’s not stupid expensive? (97 comments)
- 2025-08: Costco Diamond bridal ring set . Shall I keep it ? (85 comments)
- 2026-03: How much should you spend on engagement ring? Help a brother out (73 comments)
- 2024-03: Where did you buy your wedding/engagement rings at? (59 comments)
- 2025-12: Is this Costco ring a good deal? On sale for $3,199. Originally $4,699 (58 comments)
- 2025-07: you think i can get a good moissanite ring for around $500? (58 comments)
- 2026-03: WARNING! ***ANOTHER SCAM ALERT*** (56 comments)
- 2021-09: Where to find wedding bands that don’t cost $$$$$$$? (47 comments)
- 2025-10: If i wanted to buy a VERY cheap (under $50) loose lot of gemstones to admire/play with. Not necessarily create jewelry. What would you recommend buying? (43 comments)
- 2025-02: Engagement Ring Shopping @ Diamond District NYC (41 comments)
- 2023-08: Where can I find inexpensive wedding bands for men? (34 comments)
- 2023-06: Would you spend $450 more and custom design your ring with a private local jeweler? (28 comments)
- 2025-02: Where to buy genuine gold rings that are still affordable (28 comments)
- 2025-11: Recommendations for 2 CTW earrings? (26 comments)
- 2022-03: I want to know if the estimate quote CAD for this ring is too much (20 comments)
- 2026-03: Clueless, where to buy rings that are decent quality but reasonably priced? (15 comments)
- 2026-07: where to get good rings that look nice for $50? (15 comments)
- 2026-05: Am I asking the for too much from the jeweler? ? (14 comments)
- 2025-10: Anybody have experience buying from Etsy and/or India? (13 comments)
- 2026-08: Show off your inexpensive rings! (8 comments)
A ring counts for Etsy when its buyer named the store; the store's channel (Etsy sellers) comes from its name rather than from each buyer's description. Prices are in US dollars and cover the ring as a whole. Verdicts count one line per buyer, and only buyers who bought or priced there themselves.