engagementringcost.comBuyer-reported ring prices
All sections
MoissaniteSapphireShapes and metalsThree months' salary?Wedding bandsCustom rings and resetsRing regretWorth it?UpgradesSizingResale valueInsuranceAsking pricesBuyers' adviceUK pricesCanada pricesAustralia prices2026 prices

Where to buy · page 3 of 8 · updated September 2026

What Buyers Said About Starsgem, Blue Nile and Rare Carat

2,811 accounts, one line per buyer who used or priced a store themselves. Stores with enough reports have a page of their own; the rest are named here and nowhere else.

Previous · Page 3 of 8 · Next

StoreVerdictWhat happened
LuvanshrecommendA returnable 1.5ct lab round excellent VVS2 colorless stone listed for $272; praised the free-return policy over shopping in a physical store
LuvanshrecommendBought the same studs plus a 1ctw martini set for a sister; customer service swapped backing styles without issue, both orders arrived perfect
LuvanshrecommendBought the center stone here as part of a $1250 total ring
LuvanshrecommendOrdered a 2.44ct E VVS2 cushion stone for $446 in December 2024
LuvanshrecommendBought a 5ct lab diamond for about $1200
LuvanshrecommendHusband bought a 2ct E ideal round lab diamond ring for about $700 years ago; significantly cheaper than store options, though prices have risen slightly since
LuvanshrecommendOwns a Luvansh bracelet and was surprised by the quality; says online vendors can beat Costco on price for natural or lab stones
LuvanshwarnHad to return two items from Luvansh; wouldn't risk ordering a ring from them
Luvanshrecommend2.17ct lab diamond solitaire bought last year for $760; notes prices have gone up since
LuvanshrecommendBoyfriend ordered a diamond for a future engagement ring; writer is very pleased with it and the price, though the exact amount wasn't shared
LuvanshwarnAn earring back (about $100 pair) failed within weeks; customer service blamed quality control and offered a $60 paid replacement instead of honoring a promised free fix, and follow-through was slow even after escalation
LuvanshrecommendOrdered 2.00 ctw F-G SI 14k gold lab diamond martini stud earrings for 425; order just placed, not yet received
LuvanshrecommendBought two rings and three sets of earrings, very pleased with prices though selection is smaller than some competitors
LuvanshmixedPaid $500 for a 2.35ct VVS2 F ideal-cut loose diamond and calls them legit, though notes some other buyers had issues with finished rings
LuvanshrecommendBought a loose diamond from them before having it set elsewhere
LuvanshrecommendLoose 3ct emerald-cut stone bought here, paired with a Provence-made setting and local jeweler setting, all under $1,100 combined
LuvanshrecommendWriter bought a 5.01ct G/VS1 lab diamond here for about $1,200; says Aurelinne or Jewels by Cleo may be cheaper now
LuvanshrecommendPaid $500 for 2ct studs in 18k gold over the holidays; says the vendor has a reputation here for customer service issues but she had none
LuvanshrecommendRecommends them for fast U.S. shipping and good 14k pricing despite high gold costs; bought four pairs in different sizes and was satisfied
LuvanshrecommendBought 2ct studs for herself and 0.5ct studs for nieces; calls every pair sturdy enough for daily wear, showering and exercise
LuvanshmixedBought a loose stone only, not set; heard the loose-stone service is solid but return policy varies by stone, and a returnable stone cost about 100 dollars more than a non-returnable one
LuvanshwarnSaid the loose-stone service also isn't great since return policy is inconsistent, with some stones non-returnable when similar sites allow returns
LuvanshmixedHad the same stone-loosening problem, but the company refunded the setting cost so she could get it fixed locally
LuvanshrecommendBought a 2 carat round lab diamond pair for stud earrings in 14kt gold for $399 total; called them fabulous for the price
StarsgemrecommendCustom 3-stone trellis ring: 8x8mm asscher lab emerald with 5x5mm moissanite trillion side stones, 14k yellow gold; $390 plus $30 shipping, about four weeks turnaround, praised communication and stone quality
StarsgemrecommendPhoebe quoted $720 and sent a video of several stone sizes and hues that looked the most vivid, lively medium blue of the vendors compared.
StarsgemrecommendCustom 1.6ct VVS2 D color round lab diamond in a classic 6-prong 10K yellow gold setting, engraved with a wedding date; buyer calls the price unbeatable and the ring sturdy for daily wear.
StarsgemwarnSaid they lacked the capability to cut the requested elongated pinhole-culet old mine cut.
StarsgemrecommendCustom platinum engagement ring in progress, specified about 2.5 mm wide and 2 mm thick so it will last; praises how much the custom process lets you control
StarsgemrecommendPriced a 1.5 ct oval at about 130-150, matching Tianyu as the cheapest option compared
StarsgemrecommendOrdered five moissanite pieces made overseas by this Chinese vendor; called them stunning and worth the language barrier, said she'd never buy UK jewelry again
Starsgemrecommend3ct sterling silver moissanite ring ordered directly through a Starsgem rep for $40 plus $30 shipping; arrived in 6 days
StarsgemrecommendBought a black rose-cut moissanite; loved how unique and dark it looked compared to the gray option she'd been considering
StarsgemrecommendThis overseas maker built her moissanite ring and it turned out beautifully; a different Etsy scammer later stole her photos to resell the design as their own
StarsgemrecommendOwns several years-old 9K yellow gold rings from Starsgem and has been happy with them, noting minimal color difference versus their 14K pieces
StarsgemrecommendBought moissanite from this overseas cutter and highly recommends them
StarsgemrecommendMost-repeated overseas vendor out of 5 the writer has bought from; gives them her return business
StarsgemrecommendWonderful experience with a rep named Rose; made an 8mm trellis three-stone ring in 10k gold; chosen among three quotes based on communication.
StarsgemrecommendGreat experience buying round brilliant cuts from them
StarsgemrecommendRose-cut pear moissanite with a 1mm lab diamond halo, bought around 2019; still shown off proudly.
StarsgemrecommendBought a 3.5ct G VS1 lab stone for 1750, 2100 with the setting; has used other overseas vendors before without issue
StarsgemmixedQuoted $640 for the same earring design using a 10k gold setting plus 14k gold backing, about 5.3g total gold, same DEF/VVS moissanite quality
StarsgemrecommendBought a ring from this overseas maker and it shipped to North Carolina in just 4 days
StarsgemmixedHas bought several pieces from Starsgem, a larger company, but rates its quality and service a notch below Paston.
StarsgemrecommendOrdered a cornflower blue asscher-cut stone from Demi at Starsgem; the color sample did not match perfectly but the final stone was gorgeous, and the video-approval process before shipping was easy.
StarsgemrecommendHad the setting made here before final assembly by a local jeweler
StarsgemrecommendReports consistently positive experiences working with this rep
StarsgemrecommendCustom order came out perfect; partner previewed it before the proposal
StarsgemrecommendRemade an entire custom ring in a different shape after a design hiccup for about $30 extra, delivered fast enough for the wedding
StarsgemwarnAsked rep to fix noticeably crooked prongs on a custom ring; new photos were just taken from a different angle, prongs were never actually fixed
StarsgemwarnGroup-buy flatback earring wouldn't screw in and three jewelers said it couldn't be fixed; rep was slow to resolve and asked customer to cover half the return shipping
StarsgemrecommendOrdered around 20 pieces from this vendor community since 2020 with consistently good results
StarsgemwarnCustom order fell through at final approval; refund delayed and tied up once a bank dispute was opened, ring never shipped
StarsgemrecommendPersonally bought lab-grown diamond pieces here; excellent craftsmanship; custom rings arranged via WhatsApp contact Wendy from an inspo photo and specs
StarsgemrecommendOrdered via Alibaba; a few 2 ct lab diamond rings (not her own engagement ring) ran about $800-1,000 each
StarsgemrecommendOne of several vendors personally bought pieces from and was pleased with
Starsgemrecommend3.05ct E VVS2 round lab diamond ($490) plus platinum/rose gold basket setting ($310) via rep Demi on WhatsApp, part of a group-buy design; plus $30 shipping
StarsgemrecommendOrdered a matching 2ct lab stone ring with platinum prongs through a named rep, process going smoothly so far
StarsgemrecommendCustom 1.6ct platinum ring in progress with a different named rep, positive experience so far, no price given
StarsgemrecommendChinese vendor the writer recommends for amazing quality at a fraction of US prices
StarsgemwarnOne of several custom vendors quoted for a multi-stone diamond bracelet; came back well over $10k, up to $31k, or wouldn't go above a specified carat size
StarsgemrecommendAnother China-based lab diamond seller doing mostly custom work, similar pricing to Kuololit, good experience
StarsgemrecommendBought pieces from this lab-diamond community vendor and found them beautiful and well made
StarsgemrecommendHas bought a couple of rings from them through a group buy and calls the vendor legit with really good deals
StarsgemrecommendSays her contact there has never let her down across repeat orders
StarsgemrecommendDid a stud group buy that went smoothly, then ordered more pairs in different sizes; says settings are sturdy and never had a bad experience
StarsgemrecommendGood experience with both group buys and custom orders; notes they invoice via PayPal, giving buyers credit-card protection
StarsgemmixedQuoted $350 for a 2ct oval, no longer cheap versus Aurelinne/Calavera; colored stones run around $400 per carat
StarsgemmixedSame buyer priced this vendor alongside others before choosing, without giving a specific complaint or standout praise.
StarsgemrecommendCustom 3.06ct D VVS2 oval lab diamond with half-moon side stones in 14k gold; rep Demi handled CAD revisions and a stone-supply issue smoothly, IGI report included, arrived within about 2 weeks
StarsgemrecommendMade an aunt a large diamond set for far less than the writer expected to pay.
StarsgemrecommendHaving a 3ct D VVS2 ring made for $930
StarsgemrecommendCustom 14k-style ring with a 2ct lab diamond made via rep Tracy for about $850, roughly two years before the comment
StarsgemrecommendGot quotes from this vendor's rep (Happy) among several others and found it responsive, honest, and among the best priced
StarsgemrecommendOwns a pair sourced through an online group buy; satisfied with overall sparkle for the price paid
Blue NilerecommendFiance picked both diamond and setting online; good value
Blue NilemixedLoose certified diamonds are fine but mounts and hardware feel rough (chunky prongs, overlong earring stems); now prefers Costco
Blue NilerecommendBought wife's ring; says buyers need to learn the 4 Cs first but the prices are worth it
Blue NilemixedGood value, but ships without requiring a signature; a friend's 12k order was also left unsigned on a doorstep
Blue NilerecommendBought fiancee's ring; shipping insurance covers loss and returns
Blue NilewarnDiamond prices competitive but ring settings marked up heavily; a US-shipped stone can add over $1k in Canadian duty
Blue NilerecommendUsed a diamond buyers' forum's HCA cut-quality tool after a month of shopping in stores; says the in-store 4 Cs pitch is a marketing angle
Blue NilemixedBought a loose diamond about 13 years ago and had a local jeweler set it; good experience but ships in an unmarked box so the courier has no idea of the value
Blue NilerecommendBought a 1.6ct solitaire online for about 65% of the in-store price and is now reselling it to a jeweler for close to the full amount paid.
Blue NilerecommendBought a 1.05ct oval E VVS2 diamond with a gold milgrain band and two small accent stones.
Blue NilerecommendOrdered three rings to try on at home and returned the two unwanted ones hassle-free
Blue NilemixedNo real complaints seen, but buyer felt their prices could be lower
Blue NilemixedShopped for a .75ct princess-cut stone but Blue Nile rarely stocks lab diamonds under a carat, so bought natural instead
Blue NilerecommendMother's custom Blue Nile ring came with full certification and later appraised for more than she paid
Blue NilerecommendBought both her square-cut engagement ring and its wedding band here, mentioned with no complaints
Blue NilerecommendBought a plain 14k band there before the trip, used a local jeweler only for wife's ring sizing, under $1,000 total for both rings
Blue NilerecommendGot a 2ct ring for about two-thirds the price of a comparable Costco ring by selecting the diamond directly online
Blue NilerecommendShopped extensively and found Blue Nile cheaper than Costco with more control over stone options
Blue NilerecommendFound a much better color-grade stone at Blue Nile years earlier than what Costco had
Blue NilerecommendReturned the Costco ring for an IF clarity, I-color, ideal cut Blue Nile stone that sparkled far more
Blue NilerecommendPersonally priced similar carat and clarity there and found it noticeably cheaper than the equivalent Cartier ring
Blue NilerecommendGood reviews and strong warranty, could preview the ring before buying; came out well-made
Blue NilerecommendFound an affordable simple gold band that looked pricier than it was; a year on, no scratches or fading
Blue NilerecommendMany options at various price points without breaking the bank
Blue NilerecommendUsed Blue Nile for several diamond jewelry purchases, happy with the return policy and fair prices
Blue NilerecommendHad a Blue Nile diamond set by an outside jeweler for a reasonable cost, with free resizing and rhodium replating for life included
Blue NilerecommendSilver halo setting with a small moissanite; simple, sturdy, looks more expensive than it is
Blue NilerecommendFound a simple lab-diamond solitaire, gold band, under $700; still shines daily
Blue NilerecommendHalf-carat mined diamond solitaire in white gold bought in 2017; has held up well since
Blue Nilerecommend18k gold natural emerald-cut diamond set in platinum, bought 2022; held up well
Blue NilerecommendChose it after local jewelers felt overpriced; says the online build preview matched the delivered diamond exactly
Blue NilerecommendFound an identical 3mm 14k gold wedding band at Blue Nile for $264, cheaper than the local jeweller's AUD quote
Blue Nilerecommend0.92ct natural oval solitaire on a platinum band, bought before lab-grown diamonds became common
Blue NilerecommendPlatinum diamond band worn to the gym, swimming and gardening for over 15 years; only slight scratches
Blue NilerecommendAlmost bought in-store instead but says the online diamond's quality exceeded expectations for the price; advises reading reviews and knowing diamond grades first
Blue NilewarnHad personal issues with earrings bought from this vendor and called it overpriced with questionable quality
Blue NilerecommendUses this site to price-match before buying; also finds good deals through estate jewelry and consignment shops
Blue NilerecommendWriter bought their own ring there, loves it, and found a similar twisted-halo design in 14k white gold
Blue NilerecommendCited alongside James Allen as charging about $5,500-6,500 for a comparable stone, calling the asker's price fair.
Blue NilewarnWarned the person asking away from Blue Nile, calling it overpriced compared to other online options.
Blue NilerecommendBought a slim cathedral setting a few years ago around 800 after a discount, before gold prices rose.
Blue NilerecommendFound this vendor amazing to deal with when buying online
Blue NilewarnOrdering from this US-based vendor triggered import tariffs; declined delivery and got a full refund
Blue NilewarnOrdered stone was swapped twice for smaller replacements without her being told ahead of time; unhappy despite it working out in the end.
Blue NilerecommendBought the 2.26ct D VVS1 oval center stone here after comparing brokers plus James Allen and Whiteflash; called it the best combination of specs and visual appeal for the price despite Blue Nile being a polarizing pick among some buyers.
Blue NilewarnChecked a Blue Nile bracelet listing and found it averaged only I1 clarity while still costing more than a comparable ideal-cut option elsewhere
Blue NilerecommendAlready owns a Blue Nile diamond pendant and diamond studs from Whiteflash and says she can't tell them apart in quality, using Blue Nile as her price baseline
Rare CaratrecommendLoved the stone-viewing tool and independent gemologist rating (15/15); listed the same stone the person asking bought elsewhere at about $17,000
Rare CaratrecommendThe asker's own research on this site found 1.0-1.2 ct F VG VS1-VS2 lab diamonds priced around $1000, used as a benchmark against a local jeweler's much higher quote
Rare CaratmixedBought a 2ct lab oval ring via price match plus discounts; the $500 JM lifetime protection plan had a maintenance-compliance loophole, so writer canceled it for a partial refund.
Rare CaratrecommendUsed as a search engine to compare diamonds across sellers
Rare CaratrecommendUsed them while diamond shopping online after local jewelers couldn't match online prices for her 1.2ct marquise
Rare CaratrecommendBought a plain platinum setting around the same price as a Ritani one; noticeably heavier and better made than the comparable Ritani setting
Rare CaratrecommendBought a 2.5+ct cushion lab diamond for $948 when similar stones elsewhere were over $2,000; a local jeweler confirmed it checked out
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matched a pricier Ritani diamond, honored a lab-earring promo, and let the buyer swap the setting to a hidden halo plain band (+$10) with no shipping delay; CS rep praised
Rare CaratrecommendBought her second ring here after comparing prices elsewhere and finding it consistently cheapest; a later insurance appraisal came in well above what she paid
Rare CaratrecommendUsed the site to compare diamond prices; says the service is good and the advice comes from people not trying to sell a stone
Rare CaratrecommendFiance's ring came from here at far lower prices than Brilliant Earth; very happy with it
Rare CaratrecommendBought two diamonds from them with a flawless process; they price-match other sites if you find the same diamond cheaper
Rare CaratrecommendHad a store price-match a diamond found on Rare Carat by matching the stone's ID number
Rare CaratrecommendBought wife's ring here for $4,000 versus $10,000-12,000 quoted for comparable rings elsewhere
Rare CaratrecommendBought center stone and setting here, price-matched the stone via StoneAlgo, saved almost $3,000 versus buying in-store at Kay's
Rare CaratrecommendBought a 2.89ct princess lab diamond ring, price-matched to a competitor and setting on sale; exchanged from an earlier ring for $37 more, back in under two weeks with no issues
Rare CaratrecommendLoves her ring bought there and changed her setting; also used their price-match option to help her brother buy a surprise ring for his wife, with easy returns if she doesn't like it
Rare CaratrecommendPraised Rare Carat's quality on a prior order and has another ring on order awaiting delivery
Rare CaratrecommendComparing this online vendor's price for the picked oval solitaire design against a local jeweler quote; a JM lifetime warranty add-on through them runs $269
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matches diamonds found on Calavera; got a 2.91ct pear lab diamond ring under $900 this way
Rare CaratrecommendBought ring from Rare Carat and added a lifetime Jewelers Mutual care plan for $369 covering repairs, resizing, replating, and lost stones.
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matched a diamond also found on Calavera New York; the setting ended up costing more than the diamond; ring in production, process was easy
Rare CaratrecommendUsed the price-match process to get a 2.91ct pear ring for $862, and cites a roughly $1,029-1,238 price-matched total for a larger oval stone; praises free shipping, engraving and appraisal.
Rare CaratmixedQuoted $1800 for a 2ct seven-stone diamond band in 18K gold; the person asking felt it was kind of high
Rare CaratrecommendCalls their diamond near flawless and says it would have cost about four times as much as a natural stone elsewhere; very happy with the purchase.
Rare Caratrecommend1.79ct lab diamond with a floral halo, F color IF clarity excellent cut, under $4k total
Rare CaratrecommendReceived the ring after price-matching a 3ct lab diamond found on another site
Rare CaratrecommendHad a great experience buying a complete ring, liked the return policy, and got the lowest price for the setting she wanted
Rare CaratrecommendBought a 3 ct round, E color, VVS2, excellent polish and symmetry, no fluorescence, set as the Fern setting in 18k yellow gold with claw prongs; no price given.
Rare CaratrecommendUsed to source a natural diamond for a family member's ring; cheaper and conflict-free.
Rare CaratrecommendSpent about 3k; really good experience
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matched a cheaper listing found elsewhere and saved a lot; had to ask directly for extra sale discounts
Rare CaratrecommendGot a price match via Calavera/Aurelinne; simple process, fantastic customer service, very happy with the purchase
Rare CaratmixedReps said price-matching a gem meant losing the seasonal discount on the ring or band; still expected to save around $1,200 on the stone via price match
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matched the stone via a cert-number search on Calavera/Aurelinne/FacetLane; saved $12k on the stone but paid $1,800 more on the setting; got the band discount after requesting it
Rare CaratrecommendNo issues reported; has full coverage insurance on the ring
Rare CaratrecommendSuggests price-matching loose stones found elsewhere and mounting them here; estimates a 2ct tw earring build at or under $600, about $100 less than buying ready-made
Rare CaratrecommendTrusts it far more than any other online or local jeweler for pricing and stone quality
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matched a stone found on Aurelinne; whole 2ct oval ring came to under $1,500. They don't sell loose stones directly.
Rare CaratrecommendBought an upgrade ring plus two other rings; not the cheapest online but top-notch quality
Rare CaratrecommendPrice-matched a loose stone and built the ring; still loves it over a year later
Rare CaratrecommendWalked the person asking through asking a chat rep to price-match another listing; mentions possible freebie promos
Rare CaratrecommendSays price-matching through Rare Carat's chat has worked every time they've tried it
Rare CaratrecommendUsed their chat to price-match the stone; process was slow but worth the savings
Rare CaratrecommendBought a 2ct oval solitaire with pave despite hearing negative reviews afterward; band a bit thin but worn daily doing rough dog-boarding work with no stones lost.
EtsywarnAn attempted ring purchase fell through with a lot of drama getting the money back
EtsymixedBotched the crushed-ice stone cut and then the prong spacing twice on a custom moissanite ring, but agreed to start over from scratch and add an extra change once the buyer raised concerns
EtsyrecommendGo-to source for wedding-related purchases including jewelry, used repeatedly
EtsyrecommendSimple 14k white gold band that fit her ring; husband's band also bought there
EtsyrecommendHer $130 white gold band with channel diamonds and his $20 stainless band, both from Etsy shops
EtsyrecommendEngagement ring bought there, plus one of the two cheap wedding bands; liked supporting independent sellers
EtsymixedBlue topaz engagement ring bought there; liked it but wished she'd seen it in person first before buying during the pandemic
EtsyrecommendBought their engagement ring here
EtsyrecommendBought their vintage-style ring here, says secondhand/vintage is better value
EtsyrecommendHusband had a local Etsy artist hand-make a unique ring
EtsyrecommendHusband bought an antique-style diamond ring here at a reasonable price
EtsyrecommendBought wedding rings and an eternity ring here, though not the engagement ring itself
EtsyrecommendSent his own stone to be set in a simple bezel ring in Argentium silver; price included the CAD design and the project took about 3 weeks.
EtsyrecommendHad custom earrings made by this Etsy maker; he was flexible on style and referred her to another jeweler when a request fell outside his skillset
EtsyrecommendWedding band bought on Etsy turned out beautiful, unlike the disappointing local ring setting
EtsyrecommendBought a $60 tungsten ring that has held up over the years after local stores didn't have the right price or selection
EtsyrecommendPaid a bit over $100 total for both bands working with a nicer seller on a simple design
EtsyrecommendSwitched here after a Patrick Adair chargeback; two custom stardust rings for $252 total, transparent communication, photos sent before shipping, delivered in about two weeks
EtsyrecommendHad husband's wedding ring custom made on Etsy; no extra fees ordering to the Philippines, paid via PayPal, about a 3-week wait
EtsyrecommendBuys and sells jewelry on Etsy personally and says most legitimate sellers there have good reviews
EtsyrecommendBought platinum and 18k gold wedding bands there for $750 total, versus about $4,000 quoted at Cartier-style luxury brands.
EtsyrecommendBought an onyx-and-emerald engagement ring (~$300), a matching band (~$150) and a men's ring (~$60), all from Etsy sellers
EtsyrecommendChose Etsy specifically to find a vintage-style ring
EtsyrecommendHad this Etsy jeweler build the semi-mount setting for her pear stone; called them reputable.
EtsyrecommendCustom 14k white gold natural diamond hoops, G color VS2 clarity, more sparkle than the Costco pair, about $570 total
EtsyrecommendBought two 2.5ct VVS2 E trap-cut side stones there for about $2,000 total
EtsyrecommendHas bought several solid gold pieces from Etsy sellers that turned out to be genuinely solid gold
EtsyrecommendBought an 18k gold 3.5ct asscher-stone ring on sale from near $2,000 down to $600, plus $50 for band customization; recommends watching for Etsy sales
EtsymixedBuys loose gemstone lots from Indian Etsy sellers; requests DDP shipping to avoid tariff surcharges; uses a Presidium gem tester, and one recent seller's stones failed to test as advertised.
Etsyrecommend$40 moissanite ring, no issues, no shipping or tariff charges, about a month to arrive
EtsyrecommendBuyer has made several natural and lab-grown engagement/wedding rings through this India-based Etsy jeweler at low prices
EtsyrecommendBought from this Etsy seller; says they've been in business a while with excellent reviews, no price given
EtsyrecommendBought a stock ring from this India-based Etsy seller, in moissanite; says he also does custom work and may do lab diamonds
EtsywarnA ring that cost about $100 a few years ago now runs $800 or more across similar Etsy listings
EtsyrecommendCustom moissanite ring plus matching wedding bands arrived on time, as described, at about 1/20th the cost of the desired Brilliant Earth design
EtsyrecommendBought a half carat salt and pepper diamond in a 14k rose gold band for $800
EtsyrecommendFound via his sister browsing Etsy; called it better than 99.9% of other rings he considered, cost $505 after tax
EtsyrecommendBought a sterling silver knife-edge triangle-profile ring there as a birthday gift to herself and liked it
EtsyrecommendBought the thinnest (about 1.1mm) version of a trinity-style ring from this Etsy seller and is happy with it.
EtsyrecommendFound a secondhand vintage Stuller-brand setting on Etsy, originally sized for a 7mm stone, that ended up working well for her stone.
EtsywarnA seller received a similar phishing message on Etsy claiming an item had sold and asking her to scan a QR code, the first time she had seen that particular scam approach.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendOrdered a loose lab diamond ring, later exchanged the stone for a larger lower-clarity one; smooth CAD approval, India-based crafting routed through a NY office, IGI report and ring box both times, about 3 months total including the exchange
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendUsed the site to find a diamond then price-matched at a major vendor; got an 18k gold 3.12ct lab marquise for $4,100 shipped with a 30-day return window
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a 2.11ctw IGI-certified lab center stone here for $1,150
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendWriter's own plan: order a lab diamond stone from this vendor and have a local jeweler set it, to save money over a fully-assembled ring
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a faint-blue HPHT lab diamond from this seller and prefers its clarity and color over comparable CVD stones
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendCited as a cost-efficient site where a 4ct+ E color pear at VVS2/VS1 clarity can be found for under $1,500, beating a private jeweller's VVS1 quote at that clarity
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendCustom GIA-matched lab diamond engagement ring plus a lab-diamond-and-topaz wedding band, both 18k white gold; local jeweler verified the GIA report matched the stone
Loose Grown DiamondwarnTried to buy a stone here but heavy taxes were added at checkout and PayPal repeatedly failed to process payment; felt suspicious
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a 2.78ct radiant E VVS2 loose lab diamond here, cheaper than a comparable natural stone
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendOverseas web jeweler; bought a 3ct oval lab diamond and setting there, gorgeous result and no regrets
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought the diamond here and had a local jeweler design and set it; recommends a gallery rail and cathedral shoulder setting at least 2mm wide for durability
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendOwns a loose grown diamond from here, no further detail given
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendUsed StoneAlgo to find the cheapest price for the lab diamond bought here, then had a family-owned local jeweler make the setting
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendCertified hearts-and-arrows stone; kept buyer updated at every step, ships from factory via a New York office
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendOval lab stone plus custom platinum band, setting and spacer band done through them, all-in
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBuyer compared the local jeweler's quote to this vendor's price of around $200 for similar specs, calling the jeweler's price high by comparison
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendAlso likes browsing this site for pink lab diamonds
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a lab stone here; the identical stone was about $1000 cheaper than the same listing via stonealgo/adiamore
Loose Grown DiamondmixedUsed to find a comparable stone to price-match against Adiamor; also sells settings but writer says the setting quality is not as good, and it is not BBB accredited
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a 1.53ct loose lab stone here for $500 before having it set locally
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendFound a comparable 4ct lab ring around $2k and a diamond band around $1k, cheaper than the store's trade-in deal; later found a 9-stone 2ct 14K band there for about $1300
Loose Grown DiamondmixedCarries both colored and calibrated colorless melee at a reasonable price, but charges a flat $50 shipping fee
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a loose oval diamond from them and found them legit, though noted a few other sellers price even lower
Loose Grown DiamondmixedGood for loose diamonds and will price match, but only allows 2 returns a year, which is why she bought her complete ring elsewhere
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendVery happy with a 6.03 ct custom ring; a local jeweler confirmed the setting and prongs were secure, and production took 20 days with good updates
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendUsed to find a stone's certificate number and price-match elsewhere; writer used the same approach on a 3ct oval and saved about $2500.
Loose Grown DiamondmixedBought a loose stone but returned it because it was too large for her finger; no complaint about the vendor itself.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a stone from them and it was great; suggests checking the cert number across sites for best price and having a local jeweler do the setting
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought an elongated cushion center plus two pear side stones; HPHT side stones custom cut to size cost under half a local jeweler supplier's price; appraisal later came back about 1.5x what was paid; return window only 7 days.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendOrder arrived safely from India in about a week; packaging could be more secure but nothing was damaged.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought several loose diamonds (no jewelry from them); fast, safely packaged shipments and prompt, helpful email support including inspection requests.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a stone, spectacular customer service, easy cross-border delivery to Canada; would buy from them again.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought two pairs of 2ctw round brilliant diamonds with a PS member's help; good price and beautiful stones, set locally in a basic martini setting.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought a pair of earrings there with the help of a community member acting as a buying advisor; called the pricing very competitive
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendMatched a competitor's price without any hassle and shipped from India via New York to Sweden in about two weeks
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendReturned loose stones and received a prepaid FedEx label plus a full refund within a few days of shipping the package back
Loose Grown DiamondmixedReturned a loose diamond as a Canadian buyer; no prepaid label offered, but a promised $50 shipping rebate arrived as PayPal cash only after she pushed back on being offered store credit instead
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendParcel got flagged as a biohazard by Australian customs (not the vendor's fault) causing a stressful delay; chosen stone was too small, but the company accepted the return without issue and buyer purchased another.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendBought 4 loose diamonds, returned 1 with no issues; very happy; usually the cheapest of the vendors that share the same inventory.
Loose Grown DiamondrecommendFast, secure shipping for stones set into a five-stone ring; more sparkle and fire than lab studs bought elsewhere the year before.
Loose Grown DiamondwarnOrdered a 1.27ct center stone plus a stock 3-stone Jemima setting; delivered side stones were roughly double the approved CAD's size and the shank sat too deep on her finger; only a 7-day return window to fix it
Fioresemixed4 custom tennis bracelets bought as gifts; most broke within weeks (clasps, missing stones); Fiorese replaced all free of charge but a replacement also broke and got lost in return shipping; eventually built and shipped a new one to resolve it
FioreserecommendBought an 18k gold channel ring for about $500, then had a new platinum version of the same design made for about $800; ring has held up fine so far.
FioresemixedWorked with them twice before; lab diamond prices on the higher side though still fairly competitive; wanted as a one-stop shop for stone plus setting
FioresemixedQuoted for the elongated cushion old mine cut spec; regarded as close to the request but pricier than most, cert adds a bit more.
FioresemixedCustom OEC lab diamond order started July 2021, took six months with poor communication from Simon, but the finished ring was stunning and priced well below local options.
FioreserecommendIndividually ordered rings, necklaces, and earrings (not through a group buy) and called them all top quality
FioresewarnDuring an inquiry about a custom setting, the rep badmouthed competing overseas vendors with what felt like false claims, so chose not to order
FioresemixedOrdered diamond stud earrings asking for screw backs but received push backs instead, a bit disappointing
FioresewarnWas quoted about double what other vendors charged for a lab diamond tennis bracelet with the same specs, then later ran a group buy near the price other vendors normally charge
FioreserecommendSourcing a custom-cut elongated cushion lab diamond directly from this Chinese cutter/manufacturer via Instagram and WhatsApp; called prices super competitive and the contact very helpful
FioreserecommendWriter says this maker has been great and does custom work in both lab diamond and moissanite; also cited elsewhere for good lab diamond work.
FioresewarnWarns Fiorese's standard platinum mix uses softer palladium instead of ruthenium, which can misshape over time; recommends requesting the ruthenium mix for a small upcharge.
FioreserecommendSays pink lab diamonds are the priciest colored stones but got a good deal on one here
FioresemixedSaw a roughly 2.xx ct pink radiant priced at $1,789 there, much pricier than what another buyer paid elsewhere
FioreserecommendHaving an 8-carat lab-diamond tennis necklace custom made for $2,300, with a group-buy discount option available
FioreserecommendPersonally bought lab-grown diamond pieces here; excellent craftsmanship
FioreserecommendMade a beautiful setting for a reasonable price after the Brilliance setting was returned
FioreserecommendHas bought from other Chinese suppliers before; Fiorese isn't the cheapest but quality and service are top notch and communication is easy
FioreserecommendBought a 2.24ct old-European-cut stone for $560 plus a separate $1,100 antique-style 14kt gold band; says the vendor runs frequent specials.
FioresemixedQuoted a group-buy price for the same bracelet design, ending up about equal to Provence's quote
FioreserecommendOrdering custom earrings through a group buy from this Chinese jewelry maker, cites its strong reputation
FioreserecommendPraises Melody at Fiorese for workmanship on custom lab diamond jewelry
FioreserecommendRecommended for combined diamond-plus-setting custom work at roughly half the price of a local jeweler; writer worked personally with staff member Ayla there
FioreserecommendRecently ordered a ring through this vendor and called the craftsmanship superb, despite a higher price.
FioresemixedQuoted higher without certification than the online seller's price, though Fiorese discounts when stone and setting are bought together.
FioreserecommendWas pleased enough with a piece from this vendor that they're selling it just to reorder the same design bigger.
FioreserecommendChinese online vendor; bought a 2ct lab stone and setting separately, set locally, for under $1000 total.
FioreserecommendPicked a 3.88ct oval lab diamond after their rep showed a good selection and many stone videos
FioreserecommendSlightly pricier than the other Chinese vendors listed but still much cheaper than US options, with amazing quality
FioreserecommendA second writer says they used this vendor and were happy with the purchase, no price given
FioreserecommendCustom made a 2.5ct lab engagement ring and wedding band together for under $2k with very good quality
FioreserecommendPaid 950 for the setting; separately paid 300 elsewhere to mount a stone bought from Aurilienne.
FioreserecommendCurrently having this maker custom-build a ring; setting alone in 14k gold quoted at 900.
FioresemixedOne of several lab diamond vendors this buyer priced and compared when researching bow-tie risk in oval and elongated cushion cuts.
FioreserecommendBought a 3.0 ct crushed-ice oval lab diamond from them; praised consistent craftsmanship and low prices, though the crushed-ice cut faced up smaller than expected at that weight.
FioreserecommendNice custom work; recently had a special on OMC elongated cushion lab diamonds.
FioreserecommendBought an emerald-cut lab stone with baguette side stones; sent extensive videos before purchase, high trust in their work
FioreserecommendCurrently working with rep Bonnie at Fiorese and describes her as lovely to work with
TianyumixedTwo silver-based, gold-plated moissanite rings via Amazon, well-packaged with GRA cert and cleaning kit; craftsmanship compared to custom pieces, but one ring's double prongs sat uneven and gold plating's longevity was uncertain
TianyumixedTrinity quoted $675 plus $40 DHL shipping ($715 total) for a slightly larger 8.5mm stone, but only sent a color chart rather than real photos, leaving buyer unsure of true color accuracy.
TianyumixedQuote excludes IGI certification.
TianyurecommendHad a custom 14k white gold ring made with a 6.5 mm DEF hearts-and-arrows moissanite and moissanite side stones for about $500; result came out great
TianyurecommendPriced a 1.5 ct oval at about 130-150, by far the lowest; also sells loose stones you can take to a local jeweler for mounting
TianyuwarnQuoted $5500 for a 2ct G VS2 custom OEC lab stone but after three months couldn't cut the color white enough, order was cancelled.
TianyurecommendThe person asking loves the stones for the price (lab diamond and moissanite); another buyer has worked with the same rep for five years and says the vendor shares factory/staff photos and is transparent about designs, gold and prices.
TianyurecommendHad diamond rings custom made here and is very happy with the results
TianyurecommendBought moissanite from this overseas cutter and highly recommends them
TianyurecommendSourced a replacement lab gemstone and set it for much less than a separate vendor's high setting quote
TianyurecommendOne of two vendors the writer recommends after bad experiences with Indian sellers; usual spend range
TianyurecommendNamed as one of the writer's regular go-to AliExpress moissanite sellers, no specific order described
TianyurecommendMade a 12x8mm crushed ice oval with 6x4mm pear side stones, IJ color, set in 18k white gold.
Tianyurecommend6x8mm emerald-cut moissanite with two tapered baguettes each side, 14k yellow gold, size 8
TianyurecommendStock GHI VVS moissanite ring, 7x9mm center (3ct equivalent), 18k white-gold-plated silver, size 5.5, $98
TianyurecommendOwns a Tianyu cushion-cut three-stone ring from Amazon and loves it
TianyurecommendOwns the same Tianyu emerald-cut moissanite ring from Amazon and loves it, no issues mentioned
TianyurecommendWriter's wedding band came from this seller, no issues reported
TianyurecommendWriter personally worked with this maker and was pleased with the finished ring; also known for good lab diamond work.
TianyurecommendBought a 5.14ct E VS1 CVD diamond from them and says it's gorgeous with no visible strain issues, even under close-up video.
TianyurecommendCustom lab diamond piece via contact Ella, 2.24 ct, came in under $2,000, good craftsmanship
TianyurecommendBought via a group buy; Octavia Asscher moissanite ring, pleased with the piece
TianyurecommendBought a lab stone here and had them set it in a James Allen-inspired setting for about a $150 fee; found them easy to work with
TianyurecommendHad a great experience working with a specific rep at this vendor.
TianyurecommendQuoted both a moissanite ($615) and lab-diamond ($903) eternity band with identical specs; rep Linda helped with sizing and shape choice, final piece paired well with buyer's 3-stone engagement ring.
TianyurecommendAlso personally used this Chinese vendor for lab diamond jewelry with no complaints.
TianyurecommendChinese vendor the writer recommends for amazing quality at a fraction of US prices
TianyurecommendBought a 14k yellow gold 2.06ct lab diamond ring for under $1200, offered to answer questions about the vendor
TianyumixedQuoted for a 2.28ct D/VVS1 ideal HPHT stone; requested PayPal Friends and Family payment (flagged as a scam risk), but a tweezer video showed only slight non-noticeable bluing and good fire
TianyumixedSame buyer priced this vendor alongside others before choosing, without giving a specific complaint or standout praise.
TianyuwarnGroup buys through several reps required no reservation fee, but rep Emily gave an inaccurate nickel-free claim that caused an allergic reaction; also finds rep Anabella's pricing too high
TianyumixedCustom order had no upfront payment or reservation fee required, but production has been slow (over 2 months since paying) with mediocre communication; won't reorder
TianyuwarnQuotes from different Tianyu reps varied far more than Provence's, felt inconsistent and higher priced
TianyumixedFirst chosen lab diamond sold to someone else before purchase completed; paid a deposit to hold a second stone until the final invoice for the setting
TianyuwarnRep Sophia asked for a $100 design fee plus a $500 diamond reservation deposit, then pushed back hard with sales pressure when the person asking declined the deposit
TianyumixedGood experience buying non-diamond jewelry from them before, but found their Alibaba diamond prices for 2-3ct stones high compared to Ritani
Frank DarlingrecommendBought a 2.78 ct oval hidden-halo cathedral setting in platinum; when it sat too high, the vendor offered a free reset into their lower Plunge design within a 60-day window.
Frank DarlingrecommendChose to shop for a diamond and build a custom ring online instead of Costco or local stores; very happy with the diamond and customer service.
Frank Darlingrecommend1.5-carat lab-grown diamond in a custom setting designed with the vendor for under $6,000
Frank DarlingrecommendBought her actual engagement ring through Frank Darling and calls the experience amazing
Frank DarlingrecommendHad a custom ring made by Frank Darling, enjoyed the process, notes no minimum order size for custom work
Frank DarlingrecommendOrdered a custom ring from Frank Darling built exactly to her requests with no issues start to finish
Frank DarlingrecommendCurrently having Frank Darling customize a low, plunge-style setting so any wedding band will fit flush
Frank DarlingrecommendGoing through Frank Darling's free custom design process; experience has been great so far
Frank DarlingrecommendSkipped Tiffany's double-halo premium and bought a large stone through Frank Darling instead; happy with it.
Frank DarlingrecommendGot a 2.01ct D VS2 oval lab diamond with 0.25ct half-moon lab side stones set in platinum.
Frank DarlingrecommendCustom made a 1.06ct emerald cut F VS1 lab diamond in a platinum bezel, inspired by Tiffany Lucidia and Ceremony Dahlia settings.
Frank DarlingrecommendBought her own ring here; 2mm band in 14k yellow gold, size 3.25; no price given
Frank DarlingrecommendBought a lab-grown stone ring there; mostly e-commerce but has a real Manhattan store
Frank DarlingrecommendBought their own ring there after finding the Diamond District overwhelming and sales-y
Frank DarlingrecommendUsed the at-home try-on program and did a fully custom setting with detailed mockups and a 3D-printed preview before casting
Frank DarlingwarnHad service and quality-control hiccups, per the writer's own check of the engagement-rings group
Frank DarlingrecommendDesigner Hayley was friendly, helpful, and not pushy; called the finished ring beautiful and great quality
Frank DarlingmixedSales associate was very helpful and unbiased about lab vs. natural, but no set rings on display made it hard to picture the finished piece
Frank DarlingwarnHad an appointment booked, but its prices were astronomical compared to Lauren B for lesser-quality stones
Frank DarlingrecommendPriced the same ring style there at about $1000 USD as a North American alternative
Frank DarlingrecommendBought his loose diamond online here before having it set at a local shop
Frank DarlingwarnDiamonds looked gray and dark despite good grades and they couldn't show the right setting sizes; called the appointment a disaster
Frank DarlingrecommendDesigned her ring there in the showroom, said they work hard to fit a budget and are also good to use fully online
Frank DarlingrecommendLoved the craftsmanship of the finished ring
Frank DarlingrecommendBooked an in-showroom appointment, tried rings on, and got advice on a future wedding band; fully customizable
Frank DarlingrecommendGreat to work with, no further detail given
Frank DarlingrecommendDesigned the ring together with the vendor; free customization, multiple stones sent to review, at-home try-on and a 3D-printed preview before finalizing
Frank DarlingrecommendChose an old mine cut diamond there; free customization and better prices than local shops, though the ring must be mailed to their NYC location for resizing or repairs
Frank DarlingrecommendBought a ring there and loves it
Frank DarlingrecommendSwitched from Brilliant Earth to Frank Darling for a much cheaper, better selection; just got her ring there and loves it
Frank DarlingrecommendBought the Harper setting in 18k rose gold with a 2.0mm band, wears it daily with no issues
Frank DarlingrecommendDesigned her own ring with lab-grown diamonds here and had a good experience
Frank DarlingrecommendActively quoting the asker's ring and seems eager to earn the business; still at the quote stage
Frank DarlingrecommendBought a split-shank Plunge hidden-halo setting with a 2.5 ct oval; low profile, comfortable with no issues, plus a custom curved band to match.
Frank DarlingrecommendCustom online build with home try-ons and a resin model felt easy and safe; only gripe was slow email answers that cost the buyer a better stone deal
WhiteflashwarnThe person asking felt a precision-cut lab diamond there was priced way above what the stone itself should cost
WhiteflashwarnBuyer claiming trade experience says these branded ideal-cut sellers charge a large premium per carat without a matching quality gain and calls the site's promotion of them biased
WhiteflashrecommendPriced out a Whiteflash ACA (2.008ct I SI1) with a Vatche Tiffany-inspired setting and lifetime care plan at $20,680 total, versus $50,500 for an equivalent stone at Tiffany
WhiteflashmixedTX-based, specializes in super ideal round and princess cuts; pricier but worth an in-person visit
WhiteflashrecommendBought online; one of their in-house designers created a custom setting for the writer's ring
WhiteflashrecommendOriginal 2006 engagement ring: a .71ct natural GIA excellent G VVS2 asscher in a custom beveled bezel setting.
WhiteflashrecommendSet the writer's own engagement ring and did great work; specializes in hearts-and-arrows stones and now also carries lab diamonds
WhiteflashwarnRefused to set a diamond the writer had not purchased from them
WhiteflashrecommendRecommended alongside Brian Gavin for setting outside/loose stones; also charges a $125 fee to set stones not bought there
WhiteflashrecommendPreferred it over Costco for picking her own diamond with a better cut, even without Costco's low pricing.
WhiteflashrecommendCompared a 1.05ct H/VS2 excellent-cut stone with a platinum six-prong solitaire setting, totaling $5525 as a better-value alternative to the Costco ring
WhiteflashrecommendBuyer checked this vendor's lab diamond inventory and found a 1.2 ct E VVS2 ideal-cut stone for about $1.2k, showing the local jeweler's quote was overpriced
WhiteflashrecommendBought the center diamond here for an engagement ring and was pleased with the stone quality
WhiteflashrecommendBought a 2.6ct ACA years ago (10-15% premium); quoted $140-150k to custom-cut a 3.8-4ct F VS2 ACA via trade-in for 10th anniversary, a ~40% premium; decided to proceed
WhiteflashrecommendCustom-cut an ACA with WF targeting a 4.0-4.05ct I VS1 minimum; ended up with 4.2ct I VVS2, better than guaranteed; highly recommends WF's custom-cutting process
WhiteflashmixedBought both natural ACA diamonds and a 1ct Precision Lab diamond here; could not visually tell the lab stone apart from natural ACA, but says comparable lab quality can be had for much less elsewhere
WhiteflashrecommendChecked a bezel-set diamond that David Klass had removed for an upgrade and confirmed it had no damage.
WhiteflashrecommendRemoved a diamond from a semi-bezel Sholdt setting with no issues, letting the owner upgrade smoothly.
WhiteflashrecommendBought her diamonds here before having a Tiffany-style replica setting made elsewhere
WhiteflashrecommendOriginal ACA purchase had a customs/FedEx duty mix-up that got sorted out; ongoing support through a complex international upgrade has been responsive and helpful.
WhiteflashrecommendSays Whiteflash can customize settings and a large lab stone runs about $5k-6k there
WhiteflashmixedBuyer in Australia nearly approved a 1.04ct solitaire upgrade (replacing a 0.71ct ring) with uneven, tilted prongs visible in the first pre-shipment photos; after she flagged it, Whiteflash's production team reworked the setting over several rounds until she was satisfied and approved shipping.
WhiteflashrecommendOwns natural A Cut Above stones from here; says they edge out IDJ's cuts visually only when compared directly, though pricier
WhiteflashmixedBought an ACA specifically for the lifetime upgrade benefit, but the trade-in credit is now based on current market value, not her purchase price, making the upgrade far less appealing
WhiteflashrecommendUsed Whiteflash for a 2023 upgrade; they re-graded her unmounted stone without deducting for a downgraded clarity result
WhiteflashrecommendLongtime customer since 2017; traded in diamonds multiple times and calls Whiteflash's trade-up program the best in the business despite the shift to market-value credit
WhiteflashrecommendSales associates reassured her that a minor inclusion on her upgrade stone was inconsequential, and she completed a 2.5-carat upgrade she's thrilled with
WhiteflashrecommendRepeat customer over several diamond stud upgrades and a DBTY bracelet purchase; praised the upgrade policy and staff help choosing between comparable pairs.
WhiteflashrecommendBought a 0.804ct E SI1 round that missed ACA by one star-rating point, landing it in Expert Selection tier, which fit her budget without sacrificing color; staff fixed a wrong engraving date for free within a day and never pressured her.
WhiteflashrecommendUsed the trade-up/upgrade program to find a 2+ carat branded ideal-cut stone under budget; praised named staff and returned years later to buy two more stones and commission a custom three-stone setting.
WhiteflashrecommendCustom-built a seven-stone ACA cluster ring adapted from an existing earring design, in a low-profile platinum setting; praised for craftsmanship and customer service.
WhiteflashmixedBought diamond studs there in their premium cut line, liked the quality but regrets not choosing a bigger stone size over the fancier cut grade
WhiteflashrecommendBought a 1.9ct E VS2 A Cut Above diamond; the rep sent detailed videos, confirmed eye cleanliness under a loupe, and ran fluorescence and inclusion comparisons before the sale.
WhiteflashmixedQuoted 2900 AUD (pre-GST) for a 2.01ct F VVS2 ideal round, 1020 AUD more than a comparable Jogia stone the community judged to have better proportions
WhiteflashrecommendBought an A Cut Above 0.842ct AGS Ideal round center with hand-selected earth-mined side stones; kept original documentation and speaks positively of the piece's quality and craftsmanship while reselling it
BrilliancerecommendBought a 3 ct round lab diamond ring there after an Etsy purchase fell through, and was happy with the result
BrilliancerecommendHas made several custom rings through this site; considers it to have the lowest markup among online diamond sellers
BrilliancerecommendBought a 3.25ct lab center stone here for $2,100 after discount and tax, cheaper than Shane Co's stone pricing
Brilliancerecommend3.3ct pear stone under $2k, best price found for the same specs versus other sites
Brilliancerecommend2.18ct G VVS2 whole ring for about $1,200 with a promo code; great experience
BrilliancerecommendUpgraded ring plus matching band for about $4,000 total
BrilliancerecommendPaid $487 for an N color 2.13ct VS1 oval; likes that Brilliance stocks a wide range of colored (N-Z) diamonds most other sites don't carry

Previous · Page 3 of 8 · Next

Related on this site

Sources and method

Price reports on this page come from 193 public discussions where buyers answered in their own words. Each comment that stated what someone paid became one row; notes are paraphrased, never quoted.

The largest discussions used here (60)